“Anti-pilling” is not a complete test requirement. A fabric can receive different results when it is tested with different machines, cycle counts, specimen preparation or assessment conditions. Buyers therefore need to specify the test method and the stage at which the fabric is graded—not just ask for a pilling grade.
This guide compares the main ISO 12945 methods and explains what to request on a laboratory report. It complements our article on why fabric pills and how buyers can reduce pilling; the focus here is the test method and purchase specification.
What pilling, fuzzing and matting mean
Pilling occurs when loose surface fibres become entangled into small balls that remain attached to the fabric. Fuzzing describes raised or loose fibres on the surface. Matting is the flattening or entanglement of surface fibres into a compact layer. These changes can appear together, but they are not identical observations.
Results are influenced by fibre type and dimensions, yarn structure, fabric construction, surface finish, laundering and the way the fabric is used. A laboratory test compares specimens under controlled conditions; it does not guarantee exactly how long a garment will look new in every wearer’s conditions.
The ISO 12945 test family
The ISO 12945 series separates the main pilling exposure methods from the visual assessment method. The 2020 editions listed by ISO are:
| Standard | Method | What the apparatus does |
|---|---|---|
| ISO 12945-1:2020 | Pilling box | Specimens are exposed in a rotating pilling-box apparatus. |
| ISO 12945-2:2020 | Modified Martindale | Specimens undergo controlled rubbing on a modified Martindale tester. |
| ISO 12945-3:2020 | Random tumble | Specimens tumble in a random-tumble tester; the method covers many woven and knitted fabrics, including napped fabrics, but not fabrics that cannot tumble freely. |
| ISO 12945-4:2020 | Visual assessment | Provides a method for visually assessing pilling, fuzzing and matting. |
The ISO catalogue shows these published 2020 editions and their review history. Always confirm the edition and status required by the buyer or testing laboratory when a new order is placed.
How the three exposure methods differ
1. Pilling box — ISO 12945-1
The pilling-box method uses a rotating box apparatus to expose the mounted fabric specimens to repeated contact and movement. It is a distinct method that may be specified when it is suitable for the fabric construction and buyer’s programme; it should not be treated as interchangeable with Martindale or random-tumble results. The exact specimen preparation, box conditions and assessment stage must follow the standard and the laboratory’s controlled procedure.
2. Modified Martindale — ISO 12945-2
The modified Martindale method applies a defined rubbing motion to fabric specimens under specified conditions. It is used for a range of woven and knitted fabrics. Do not confuse a pilling test performed on a Martindale tester with a Martindale abrasion-resistance test: the machine family may be related, but the test purpose, setup and reporting are different.
Important distinction: ASTM D4970/D4970M is a separate Martindale pilling method, not another name for ISO 12945-2. ASTM’s active D4970/D4970M-22(2026) edition says the method is not recommended for acceptance testing because interlaboratory data are unavailable; if buyer and supplier nevertheless use it for acceptance, ASTM advises caution and comparison of laboratory results where needed. Agree the method and acceptance basis before relying on a grade.
3. Random tumble — ISO 12945-3
The random-tumble method exposes specimens to movement in a random-tumble apparatus. ISO describes it as applicable to most woven and knitted fabrics, including napped constructions such as fleeces and inlay fabrics. It is not applicable to fabrics that cannot tumble freely. The buyer should confirm that the construction is suitable before requesting this method.
Understanding the visual grade
Pilling results are commonly assessed against visual reference standards. A 5-to-1 scale is used in widely applied procedures, with grade 5 representing no visible pilling or the best surface appearance and grade 1 representing very severe pilling. Intermediate grades indicate progressively greater surface change. The precise assessment procedure should follow the named method and visual-assessment standard.
A grade without its test method and exposure stage is incomplete. “Grade 4” alone does not tell the buyer whether the sample was tested by pilling box, Martindale or random tumble, how long it was exposed, whether it was washed first, or whether the grade is an individual specimen result or a reported average.
Why two laboratories may report different grades
- Different methods: the pilling box, Martindale and random-tumble apparatus do not create the same type of surface exposure.
- Different exposure stages: a specimen may look acceptable at an earlier cycle or revolution count and worse after further exposure.
- Different sample condition: finishing, laundering or dry-cleaning before the test can affect surface behaviour. Agree the condition before testing.
- Different fabric structure: fibre blend, yarn twist, density, knit or weave structure and raising/finishing treatments can change the result.
- Different visual assessment: lighting, reference photographs, specimen orientation and assessor consistency matter.
ASTM’s Martindale pilling method also notes that pilling is complex and depends on fibre, yarn, fabric construction and finishing. It cautions against treating a laboratory result as a direct prediction of every wearer’s real-life experience.
What to write in a fabric purchase order
For a meaningful pilling requirement, write the following details rather than using only the phrase “anti-pilling quality”:
- Test standard and edition, for example ISO 12945-1:2020 or ISO 12945-2:2020.
- Required exposure stage or cycle/revolution count, exactly as specified by the buyer’s method.
- Whether the fabric is tested as received or after an agreed laundering or dry-cleaning treatment.
- Visual assessment standard and rating scale.
- Minimum acceptable grade and whether it applies to every specimen or the reported result.
- Fabric quality, colour, finish, lot and sample identification so the test report can be matched to the bulk order.
Do not copy a grade limit from another buyer or fabric type. Agree the method and acceptance grade for the actual end use. If the buyer requires a post-wash result, state the wash procedure and number of cycles separately; “after wash” is not precise enough on its own.
Questions to ask when reviewing the test report
- Does the report name the exact test method and edition?
- Does it state the exposure stage and specimen condition?
- Are the individual specimen grades and the reported result clear?
- Does the report identify the fabric construction, composition, colour and finish tested?
- Was the tested sample taken from the approved development or the actual bulk lot?
- Does the result meet the acceptance limit written in the order?
For related checks, review our pre-cutting fabric shrinkage test checklist and fabric RFQ checklist. Pilling is only one part of fabric performance; dimensional stability, colourfastness, appearance and end-use requirements may also need separate approval.
References and image credit
- ISO 12945-1:2020 — Pilling box method.
- ISO 12945-2:2020 — Modified Martindale method.
- ISO 12945-3:2020 — Random tumble pilling method.
- ISO 12945-4:2020 — Visual assessment of pilling, fuzzing and matting.
- ASTM D4970/D4970M-22 — Martindale pilling resistance method.
Featured image: “Pilling TRIWITEX.png” by Tim Mockert, Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0. The photograph shows a specimen from a pilling assessment mounted on a cylindrical holder; it does not establish the test method, grade or pass/fail result. The file has been resized for web display; no other changes were made.



