A fabric can be made with chemical formulations that conform to a Manufacturing Restricted Substances List (MRSL) and still require finished-material testing against a buyer’s Restricted Substances List (RSL). The reverse is also true: a test result for one finished-fabric sample does not prove that every chemical used in production was controlled at source. These are related controls, but they answer different questions.
For fabric buyers, sourcing teams, mills and dyeing or finishing partners, the distinction becomes practical when a mill, dyehouse and garment buyer need to show who controlled the process chemicals and whether the finished fabric meets the buyer’s test requirements. The sections below explain what evidence belongs to each control and how to keep the two records connected to the same production lot.
RSL and MRSL: the essential difference
RSL (Restricted Substances List) sets restrictions or limits for specified substances in a finished product, material or product component. It is checked downstream, using the relevant product requirements and test methods.
MRSL (Manufacturing Restricted Substances List) controls specified substances in chemical formulations used during manufacturing. It is applied upstream, before and during production, to help prevent restricted substances from entering the process through dyes, auxiliaries, detergents, finishes and other chemical products.
ZDHC describes its MRSL as a list of substances banned from intentional use in manufacturing processes. It explicitly distinguishes this upstream input control from traditional RSLs that focus on finished products. See the ZDHC MRSL overview.
RSL vs MRSL: a buyer’s comparison
| Question | RSL | MRSL |
|---|---|---|
| What is controlled? | Substances restricted in the finished material, product or defined component. | Substances restricted in chemical formulations used in manufacturing. |
| When is it applied? | At product or material approval, and at the testing or verification stages required by the buyer. | When selecting, approving, purchasing and using process chemicals. |
| Typical evidence | Buyer-specific RSL, applicable regulatory requirements, material test reports and component or lot traceability. | Chemical inventory, product identity, safety data, supplier declarations and applicable MRSL conformance evidence. |
| What does a positive result show? | The tested sample met the stated limits for the substances and methods included in that test scope. | The identified chemical formulation has evidence of conformance to the stated MRSL version and assessment level. |
| What does it not prove by itself? | It does not prove that every process chemical was controlled or that untested substances are absent. | It does not automatically prove that the finished fabric or garment passes every buyer RSL or legal requirement. |
Neither document replaces the other. A supplier should not use an MRSL declaration as a substitute for a finished-material RSL test when the buyer requires that test. Equally, a single RSL test report is not a complete chemical-management system for the factory.
What should a fabric buyer check under an RSL?
The RSL must be matched to the exact product, market, buyer and material scope. A woven fabric specification should identify, as applicable, the fibre composition, colour or print, coating or finish, intended end use, skin-contact conditions and any special product category. The test matrix may differ for cotton, polyester, cotton-polyester blends, coated fabrics, prints and other components.
For apparel and footwear supply chains, the AFIRM Restricted Substances List, Version 11 (2026) is a useful industry reference. AFIRM states that member brands can differ on individual parameters and that suppliers should check the customer’s specific requirements. AFIRM also explains that its RSL is a resource for supply-chain participants, not a substitute for legal advice or an individual brand’s implementation instructions.
Before arranging a test, request the buyer’s current RSL and testing matrix rather than choosing a generic panel from memory. Confirm:
- the exact RSL name, version and issue date;
- the product and material category to which each requirement applies;
- the restricted substance or substance group, limit and unit;
- the required test method and edition, including any material-specific preparation;
- whether the test is required on greige fabric, dyed or finished fabric, a print or coating, or the finished garment;
- the required sampling plan, report format and laboratory acceptance criteria.
Do not assume that a test panel for one fabric colour or construction automatically covers every colour, finish or production lot. The buyer’s risk assessment and written testing plan should define what must be sampled and when.
What should a mill check under an MRSL?
MRSL control starts with the chemical products entering the process. For woven fabric, this can include dyes, pigments, wetting agents, detergents, scouring agents, bleaching chemicals, sequestering agents, fixing agents, softeners, resins, water-repellent treatments, coating chemicals and printing auxiliaries, depending on the route used.
For each relevant formulation, record the commercial product name, manufacturer, supplier, product code, batch or lot, intended process, current safety data sheet and the evidence used to assess MRSL conformance. A supplier declaration is useful information, but buyers should understand what it covers and whether it is supported by an accepted third-party assessment or other evidence required by the programme.
ZDHC’s Gateway tools have different purposes. ChemCheck provides information about chemical products and their MRSL conformance; InCheck helps a manufacturing site review and report on its chemical inventory. These are chemical-management tools, not finished-fabric RSL test reports. See the ZDHC MRSL and Gateway information.
Important 2026 reference updates
AFIRM RSL Version 11 (2026)
AFIRM’s 2026 RSL is Version 11. Its change log includes the addition of acetophenone azine with a 50 ppm limit, changes to bisphenol limits, updated test-method references for selected substance groups, and additional PFAS guidance. The document also discusses the challenge of legacy chemicals in recovered or recycled materials. These entries are not universal limits for every textile material: always check the table, material scope, footnotes and buyer-specific instructions before applying a value to an order.
AFIRM also notes that its member brands may differ in their individual parameters and in the testing they accept. The 2026 document is therefore a reference for supplier preparation, not proof that every buyer adopts the same matrix.
ZDHC MRSL Version 4.0 (October 2026)
ZDHC’s official change log identifies MRSL Version 4.0 as an October 2026 update. Among the listed changes, the specified NPEO and OPEO limits are reduced from 250 mg/kg to 100 mg/kg. The update also revises PFAS definitions and testing provisions. For unintentional PFAS contamination in formulations, the ZDHC page describes limits below 25 µg/kg for an individual PFAS and below 250 µg/kg for the sum of PFAS; it also states that Level 1 MRSL testing is mandatory for PFAS.
Important: these are formulation-level MRSL provisions in the ZDHC framework. ZDHC’s transition notice, updated 29 October 2026, states that the move from V3.1 to V4.0 began on 1 November 2026. Formulation recertification is scheduled to start on 1 February 2027 and finish on 1 November 2027; the supply-chain implementation period ends on 1 June 2028. These are ZDHC programme milestones, not statutory textile-law deadlines, and a brand or buyer may set an earlier contractual date. During the transition, verify the version and status of each formulation with its supplier or approved conformance indicator and follow the buyer’s written implementation timetable. See the ZDHC transition timetable.
They must not be copied into a finished-fabric RSL specification as if they were universal fabric limits. Check the full current MRSL, its applicability notes and the buyer’s requirements. Read the ZDHC MRSL V3.1 to V4.0 change log and the current ZDHC MRSL page.
How the two controls work together in a fabric supply chain
A practical control system connects the chemical input records to the final material that the buyer receives. This is especially important when weaving is completed at one site and dyeing or finishing is carried out by an approved external processor.
- Obtain the buyer’s current requirements. Collect the applicable RSL, MRSL reference, testing matrix, material scope and any brand implementation manual. Record the version and date so the team does not work from an obsolete file.
- Map the process route. List the stages used for the fabric, including pretreatment, dyeing, washing, printing, coating and finishing where applicable. Identify which facility performs each stage and who controls the chemical purchase and recipe.
- Build a chemical inventory. Ask the process site to list the chemical formulations used for the relevant fabric and process. Match each item to its manufacturer, product code and current supporting documents. Do not rely on a generic statement that a factory is “MRSL compliant” without knowing which process and products it covers.
- Check the evidence for each chemical. Review the relevant MRSL version, conformance information and validity or status shown by the recognised programme. If a formulation is not listed or the evidence is unclear, ask the chemical supplier for clarification and agree how the risk will be managed before use.
- Control substitutions and recipe changes. Require the processor to obtain approval before replacing a dye, auxiliary or finishing product with an unreviewed alternative. Keep the product code, batch, recipe and production-lot records so that a later investigation can trace what was used.
- Test the finished material when required. Arrange final-fabric or component testing against the buyer’s RSL using the agreed material scope, methods and sampling plan. A chemical input assessment does not replace this step.
- Review the report and retain traceability. Check sample identity, method, laboratory scope, result, limit, units and any deviations. Link the report to the fabric lot, colour, process site and shipment records. Our guide to reading a textile test report explains these checks in more detail.
Special attention for recycled and blended materials
Recycled content can introduce a different chemical-risk profile because substances used in an earlier product life may remain in recovered material. AFIRM’s 2026 RSL specifically notes that recycling can unintentionally reintroduce legacy chemicals that are now restricted. A recycled-content claim or chain-of-custody document does not, by itself, establish chemical compliance.
For recycled polyester, recycled cotton or blended fabrics, confirm the buyer’s material-specific testing matrix and any recycled-material guidance. Ask how the feedstock is controlled, what traceability is available and whether the test plan accounts for the material’s risk profile. Do not assume that a virgin-material test plan is automatically sufficient for recycled content.
REACH and brand RSLs are not the same thing
REACH is a European Union chemicals regulation; an RSL is a product-restriction list used by a brand, industry group or other programme. They can overlap, but they are not interchangeable. For example, ECHA explains that EU or EEA suppliers of articles containing a Candidate List substance above 0.1% weight by weight in the relevant article or constituent component have information duties under REACH Article 33. Other REACH restrictions and product-specific rules may also apply.
The 0.1% threshold is not a general “safe limit” for every chemical in every textile. It relates to particular REACH Candidate List communication obligations for substances in articles. Check the current ECHA Candidate List, the relevant legal provision and the product’s actual market. See ECHA’s summary of Candidate List obligations.
RFQ wording buyers can adapt
Please confirm the current buyer RSL and MRSL requirements applicable to this fabric, including version, material scope, test matrix and required methods. Identify the facilities performing pretreatment, dyeing, printing and finishing, as applicable. Provide the chemical inventory for the relevant process and supporting MRSL conformance evidence for the formulations used. No chemical product or recipe substitution may be made without prior review and approval. Where required by the buyer’s testing plan, submit a final-material RSL test report that identifies the tested fabric, colour, production lot, method, laboratory and results against the specified limits. Please retain the process and lot records needed to trace the tested material to bulk production.
This wording is a starting point, not a universal compliance clause. Adapt it to the buyer’s actual programme and contract.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Calling a finished fabric “MRSL certified” when the evidence actually applies to a chemical formulation or chemical-management programme.
- Claiming that an MRSL-conformant chemical automatically makes the finished fabric RSL compliant.
- Using an old RSL or MRSL version without checking the buyer’s latest requirements.
- Assuming that one colour, one sample or one production lot represents every variation in an order.
- Accepting a generic supplier declaration without checking the product identity, process scope and supporting evidence.
- Describing a fabric as “PFAS-free” or “chemical-free” based only on a limited test panel or a chemical supplier’s declaration.
Final buyer checklist
- Current buyer RSL and MRSL versions recorded.
- Correct fibre, colour, finish and end-use scope confirmed.
- All relevant process sites and chemical suppliers identified.
- Chemical inventory and MRSL evidence checked for the applicable formulations.
- Substitution control and lot traceability agreed.
- Finished-material RSL testing completed where required by the buyer.
- Test reports reviewed against the exact limits, methods and sampling plan.
- Any deviations, gaps or corrective actions closed and documented.
In practice, MRSL controls what goes into the manufacturing process, while RSL checks what remains in the finished material. Buyers need both records: one for the chemicals used at each processing site and one for the tests required on the fabric or garment supplied.
Official references
- ZDHC — MRSL: The foundation for safer chemical management.
- ZDHC MRSL V3.1 to V4.0 Change Log, October 2026.
- AFIRM Restricted Substances List, Version 11 (2026).
- ECHA — Obligations resulting from inclusion of SVHCs in the Candidate List.
Image credit: Casey Strauch, “Hohenstein Quality Testing,” Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0. Used unmodified. The image shows textile testing technicians in a laboratory; it is illustrative and does not depict a specific RSL or MRSL test, Hubei Jintian facility or compliance result. Original image and licence details.
This article is general supply-chain guidance, not legal advice or a certification statement. Always follow the current buyer manual, applicable law, full standard or programme document and written purchase specification for the actual order.



